Airtel Super Singer junior 2, Award winning songs round
Day 4 - April 8, 2010
Saturday, April 10, 2010
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
skip to main |
skip to sidebar
Who will be Airtel Super Singer 3
Blog Archive
-
▼
2010
(256)
-
▼
April
(17)
- Tribute to MS Viswanathan Round, 29-04-2010
- Tribute to MS Viswanathan Round, 28-04-2010
- Tribute to MS Viswanathan Round, 27-04-2010
- Tribute to MS Viswanathan Round, 26-04-2010
- Unplugged Round, 22-04-2010
- Unplugged Round, 21-04-2010
- Unplugged Round, 20-04-2010
- Unplugged Round, 19-04-2010
- Chithirai thirunaal special, 15-04-2010
- Chithirai thirunaal special, 14-04-2010
- Chithirai thirunaal special, 13-04-2010
- Chithirai thirunaal special, 12-04-2010
- Award winning songs Round, 08-04-2010
- Award winning songs Round, 07-04-2010
- Award winning songs Round, 06-04-2010
- Award winning songs Round, 5-04-2010
- Retro Round, 1-04-2010
-
▼
April
(17)
Disclaimer
This is a personal blog. This blog just provides a snapshot of the knowledge, views, and opinions that I/content writer hold at a particular point of time and these might most probably change over a period of time. I reserve the right to evolve my knowledge, thoughts, and viewpoints over time and to change them without assigning any reason. My blog includes links to other sites/blogs operated by third parties. These are provided as a means of convenient access to you to the information/opinion contained therein. I am in no way responsible for the content of any other sites or any products or services that may be offered through other sites.
The talent of the Child participants are outstanding and they can be on par with any Leading play back singer today. It is very difficult to say who is the best as each one excels in his / her own style on a given situation and mesmerize the audience / viewers.It is a tough task for Judges to select the best singer on each episode and some times they may err in their judgement which is unintentional. However they cannot be biased.
ReplyDeleteBut to my shock and I could notice that there is a sense of bias towards a singer ,shown by the two judges namely Mrs Chitra and Mr Mano, when they were trying to eliminate one participant who sang well to favour another participant who did not perform well that day. This shocked not only the entire audience but the viewers as well . But by providence this was nullified by the intervention of the special Guest who was present that day , may be the Guest was also shocked by the elimination.
Yes, this I saw in the episode telecast yesterday ( 8th April 10).The methodology followed by the Judges so far for elimination is that the person with least marks will be dropped. But yesterday they followed a strange method. The two participants with least score were Nithyasree and Roshan.. They did not declare the score of each participant( going by the comments and observation of the Judges and the chief guest ,Nithyasree sang very well.The chief Guest walked o n to the stage and hugged her as a gesture and appreciation of her outstanding performance) It was obvious that Roshan was the lowest scorer and would have got eliminated.
To retain Roshan and eliminate Nithyasree , they manipulated and adopted a strange method and created pressure on the little girl and made her nervous (and not the quick fire round method what they followed in case of tie) and there was a rush in their approach to eliminate Nithyasree . The Chief Guest Mrs Janaki who had all appreciation for Nithyasree for her outstanding talent , obviously got disappointed ,intervened and objected the elimination. Thus the elimination was dropped.
This showed clearly the two judges were biased towards Roshan. Nithyasree is one of the outstanding talent of the show with her excellent ability to sing with voice modulation all type of songs with confidence and boldness which was well appreciated by the Great legendary Mrs Janaki herself and Nithyasree was the most consistant performer of the show.
This is a talent show . The real talent has to be appreciated . There cannot be bias . The judges have to be neutral and impartial. No doubt Chitra and Mano are great renowned Singers ,but unfortunately they do not make good Judges.
Yes,in talent show to identify the best and declare the winner , elimination of lesser talents is a must . For that you need impartial Judges. Yes , you need to have elimination round for Judges first.
“ Drop incompetent Judges” before next round
Vijay TV has a reputation for Quality shows.You have the responsibility towards audience / viewers to present Quality programmes by all fair means. You cannot afford to have incompetent Judges who spoil the same
CHITRA AND MANO BIASED!!!!!!!!!!!
ReplyDelete“ Drop incompetent Judges” .
WRONG DECISSION TO BRING NITHYASREE INTO DANGER ZONE !!!! whom S.JANAKI herself applauded !!!
Pls note 3rd judge Subha also told 8apr2010 nithyasree's performance was her Best .....
This is a talent show . The real talent has to be appreciated . There cannot be bias . The judges have to be neutral and impartial. No doubt Chitra and Mano are great renowned Singers ,but unfortunately they do not make good Judges.
Chitha and Mano seem biased towards Alka and Roshan. Alka seemed shocked to have entered the danger zone. Hope this is a wake up call for her in not being too overconfident about winning the title.
ReplyDeleteBut we have to realise that there are other singers in the Top 7 who have shown significant improvement since entering the competition i.e. Shravan, Srinisha and Nithyashree.
The requirement for the danger zome contestants to sing an unfamiliar song should only be brought in for a tie breaker. Besides, these are only children...give them a break!
Completed agree with all the comments above. Mano and Chithra are amazing singers but have proved to be very disappointing as judges.
ReplyDeleteTheir judgement on Nityashree was very unfair. It appeared as if they were waiting to eliminate Nityashree, when she consistently got good feedback on all the 3 rounds. Mano's calculations were ridiculous on the # of repetitions Nityashree made. it was outright unfair when their favorite Roshan used 'la la la la' instead of actual words. This is outright torture for the kids. Nityashree is an outstanding singer & a very talented kid. She dances and sings with such ease, which Janakiamma herself praised.
Vijay TV, if you want to maintain your reputation, please remove Chithra and Mano. They are both outwardly biased towards Alka and Roshan, even if they dont perform well.
SUJATHA said
ReplyDeleteTHE JUDGEMENT GIVEN BY MANO AND CHITRA MAY NOT BE PERFECT, BUT THEY WOULD LIKE TO GIVE PRIORITY FOR GOOD QUALITY VOICES. tHOUGH NITHYSREE MAY HAVE TALENT, HER VOICE IS CHILDISH. I FEEL THAT SOME GOOD VOICES LIKE PRIYANKA SHOULD NOT HAVE BEEN ELIMINATED AS THESE SWEET VOICES BRING INTEREST TO WATCH THIS SHOW. PRIYANKA'S ELIMINATION IS A BIG LOSS TO THE VIEWERS AND TO OUR EARS. SHE MUST BE BROUGHT BACK TO THE SHOW THRU WILD CARD ROUND AS SHE IS FIT FOR THE TITLE OF " TAMILAKATHIN CHELLAKURAL" , hER VOICE IS MUCH SWEETER THAN ALKA'S VOICE. FOR A GOOD SINGER VOICE IS IMPORTANT WITHOUT WHICH HOW MUCH EVER GOOD THEY SING , IT WON'T BE SO GOOD TO LISTEN. SO, I STILL VOTE FOR PRIYANKA. COME BACK FOR PRIYANKA.